Chapter 2: Voices Beneath the Steeple - The Secrets in the Roots of 1st Row
To truly understand the story of St. James Anglican Church in Wilmot Township, you must walk back to where the roots run deepest. Tucked along the quiet tree line, shaded by the mature canopy, lies the oldest standing section in the entire churchyard; recorded as Row 15 in the Ontario Genealogical Society (OGS) transcripts, but undeniably Row 1 by right of age.
When you clear away the fallen leaves and brush away a century of lichen along this tree line, you are looking directly at the foundation of this settlement. These are the stones of the military officers who served the Crown, the courageous mothers who crossed the Atlantic from Devonshire and Lincolnshire, and the young children whose gentle markers remind us of the harsh reality of pioneer life.
Here, stone by stone along this historic first row, are the stories of the pioneers who sleep beneath the canopy.
Row 1 Stone 1: Elizabeth ‘Eliza’ (Barber) Squires (1824-1895)
The first stone in this historic line stands as a silent sentinel to the cemetery's earliest days, where soft marble tablets were carefully raised by grieving hands long before municipal registries even existed in Upper Canada. It sets the tone for this ancient row; a place where every weathered character carved into marble holds a piece of our shared settlement history. This stone was fun, when I arrived, there was not even a mention of this stone on find a grave. It was listed on the OGS records, but no connections and no mention of family, until we cleaned the stone.
· inscription: Mother / Eliza / wife of Henry SQUIRES / died / Feb. 11, 1895 / aged 70 years / 1 mo. 11 ds / SQUIRES / "Jesus has called the mother home / her flesh lies mouldering in the tomb / God grant her offspring may be blest / And meet her in eternal rest"
Born in the cold depths of winter on December 31, 1824, Eliza entered a world defined by transition. The third child of her family, the youngest daughter of four. Eliza’s parents were Robert Barber (Barbour) and Elizabeth Shaw (1796-1846). Born in Ireland and arriving in 1837, the following family record provides the details needed to piece together the family of Eliza. Many thanks to the family member that created this family, you have done my work for me or at least provided the map to the journey.
Based on the facts, Eliza came of age during the height of Upper Canadian settlement, eventually marrying Henry Squires and making her home in Waterloo County, where the Squires family established deep roots as hard-working agricultural pioneers.
Life as a pioneer mother in 19th-century Wilmot Township required an unimaginable level of resilience. Eliza managed the daily demands of a rural household, tending to the hearth, preserving harvests, and raising children in an era before modern medical care, electricity, or paved roads. Cross-referencing census records and local land entries reveals a family woven tightly into the agrarian growth of the region; one of many homesteading couples whose quiet, daily labors turned the dense bush along the Huron Road into thriving farmland.
When Eliza passed away on February 11, 1895, at the age of 70 years, 1 month, and 11 days, her family chose to enshrine her life not by civic title or material status, but by her most sacred role: Mother. Paying homage to the woman that gave life and protected it.
The verse hand-carved into her white marble marker is a stark, moving piece of late-Victorian epitaph poetry. Lines like "her flesh lies mouldering in the tomb" may strike the modern reader as somber or direct, but to the pioneer families of the 1890s, this language was a honest expression of physical mortality paired with ultimate Christian hope. It reflects a family leaning heavily on faith, praying that Eliza’s hard-won devotion would carry through her descendants, her "offspring", until they could be reunited in quiet peace.
Cleaning Eliza’s stone as the very first marker in Row 1 brings her back into focus. Lifting away decades of dark environmental patina to reveal that gentle title, Mother, restores a tangible link to one of Wilmot’s early matriarchs, ensuring her place at the head of this historic row is honored for generations to come. Reunited at rest with her mother and brothers, in the hallowed ground of St. James. We not only find Eliza here, but some of her family as well, what a marvellous reunion this will be.
Row 1 Stone 2: Lt. Walter Campbell (1792-1857), Matilda Augusta Campbell (1844-1866) & Mary A. Campbell (1806-1866)
Standing directly alongside Eliza Squires in Row 1, Stone 2 carries an extraordinary presence. This striking marker holds the weight of British military heritage and Scottish nobility, linking our quiet corner of Wilmot Township directly to the Scottish Highlands and the global reach of the British Empire.
· Inscription: (Southwest side): Sacred to the memory of Lieut. Walter CAMPBELL, late HM's 37 Regt, died April 25, 1857, aged 65 years.
· Inscription: (Northeast side): Sacred to the memory of Matilda Augusta CAMPBELL, died Mar. 5, 1865, aged 22 years. Also Mary A. CAMPBELL, died Sept. 7, 1866, aged 60 y'rs 2 d's, relict of the late Archibald B. CAMPBELL of Glenure Scotland.
Lieutenant Walter Campbell served his country in Her Majesty's 37th (North Hampshire) Regiment of Foot; a distinguished infantry regiment of the British Army that saw action across the globe during the Napoleonic era and late Georgian period. Officers like Walter represented a specific class of Upper Canadian pioneer. Following their military service, retired British officers were frequently awarded strategic Crown land grants across the province, brought in to bring leadership, civic structure, and loyalty to developing townships along vital military and trade corridors like the Huron Road.
Passing away in the soft light of spring on April 25, 1857, at 65 years of age, Lieutenant Campbell was among the earliest gentrified settlers to be laid to rest beneath the trees at St. James. His presence here speaks to the sheer variety of people who carved out Wilmot’s history; where British officers traded dress uniforms for the quiet, rugged life of rural township gentry.
Sharing this sacred plot are two women whose names connect Wilmot directly to one of the most famous estates in Scottish history: Matilda Augusta Campbell and Mary A. Campbell.
Mary A. Campbell passed away on September 7, 1866, just two days after celebrating her 60th birthday. The marble face explicitly records her as the "relict" the 19th-century legal term for widow, of the late Archibald B. Campbell of Glenure, Scotland.
To anyone familiar with Highland history, the mention of Glenure carries profound weight. Located in Argyll, the Glenure estate was central to Clan Campbell history; immortalized in Scottish lore as the seat of Colin Campbell, the "Red Fox" of the historic 1752 Appin Murder. As laird of Glenure, Mary's husband Archibald B. Campbell held a position of near-regal authority. In the Highland feudal tradition, the Chieftain and Lairds of Glenure functioned not merely as estate owners, but as absolute patriarchal rulers of their clan lands, holding hereditary judicial authority, collecting rents, managing tenant crofters, and maintaining the prestige of a lineage directly descended from the Earls of Argyll and the Royal House of Stewart.
Archibald B. Campbell died and was buried across the Atlantic, remaining in Scottish soil on his ancestral Highland lands. Following his death, his widow Mary, carrying the royal bloodlines and noble heritage of Glenure, made the arduous journey across the ocean with their young children to join Lieutenant Walter Campbell in Canada.
For Mary to carry the name of Glenure from the rugged glens of Argyll across the Atlantic to the pioneer soil of Waterloo County reminds us just how far our early settlers traveled to build a new life, bringing their ancient lineage into the Canadian bush.
Tragically, the family endured devastating heartbreak in the years surrounding the Confederation of Canada. Just eighteen months before Mary’s passing, the family lost young Matilda Augusta Campbell on March 5, 1865, at just 22 years of age. To stand before this stone today is to feel the profound sorrow of a mother watching her young daughter taken far too soon, only for Mary to rejoin her in the quiet earth a short year and a half later.
Lifting decades of dark lichen and moss off Stone 2 reveals crisp, elegant lettering that spans continents; from the parade grounds of the 37th Regiment and the ancient halls of Glenure to a peaceful resting place right here beneath the Wilmot canopy, deep within the roots.
Row 1 Stone 3: Eva Maria Smith (1866-1879)
There is a tender, sharp sorrow that comes with cleaning the marker of a child. Eva Maria Smith was the cherished thirteen-year-old daughter of William C. and Henrietta Smith. Passing away in the late summer of 1879; an era when seasonal fevers and childhood illnesses frequently swept through rural farmsteads without warning. Eva’s life was measured precisely down to 13 years, 4 months, and 10 days.
Eva was born in May 1866, right on the eve of Canadian Confederation. Her parents, William C. and Henrietta Smith, were established members of the surrounding agricultural community, building their farmstead during a period of rapid economic growth in Waterloo County.
Life for a teenage girl in 1870s Wilmot Township revolved around the rhythm of home and parish life; helping manage the household, attending school, and participating in church services at St. James. Her sudden loss in September 1879, at just thirteen years old, struck at the very heart of the family.
· Inscription: IN MEMORY OF / EVA MARIA / DAUGHTER OF / WILLIAM C. & HENRIETTA / SMITH / WHO DIED / SEP. 26, 1879, / AGED 13 YEARS / 4 M'S. & 10 D'S. / HE GIVETH HIS BELOVED SLEEP / PSALM CXXVII. 2.
Eva’s marker is a classic, light-grey granite tablet set into a bevelled concrete base. Granite was a far more durable, premium choice for the late 1870s, which explains why the lettering has survived in such extraordinary, crisp condition. Standing quietly along the fence line under the shade of the mature pines, the stone has escaped the severe sugar-granulation erosion that typically plagues soft marble tablets of this era. Clearing away the light lichen and organic buildup along the face reveals the clean, hand-chiseled block and Roman lettering, allowing the precise dates so show, thus why this stone was chosen by her grieving parents, to stand out.
For her final epitaph, William and Henrietta selected a deeply comforting line of scripture from Psalm 127:2: "He giveth His beloved sleep." In an era when civil death registrations were in their infancy and medical treatments for sudden illnesses were limited, faith was often the sole anchor for grieving parents. The verse reflects a quiet, enduring hope; a mother and father committing their young daughter into peaceful rest, anchored forever beneath the trees at St. James.
Row 1 Stone 4: Henry Puddicombe (1803 – 1882) and Elizabeth Stockwell Puddicombe (1802-1872)
Stone 4 brings us face-to-face with one of the most foundational surnames in Wilmot Township: the Puddicombes. A name that shaped the community, church and cemetery, to this day scripted proudly on many of the stones beneath the steeple.
· Inscription (South side): In memory of Elizabeth STOCKWELL, wife of Henry PUDDICOMBE, who died July 16, A.D. 1872, in the 70th year of her age. A native of Cambridge, England.
· Inscription (East side): In memory of Henry PUDDICOMBE, who died May 2, A.D. 1882, in the 79th year of his age. A native of Beaford, Devonshire, England.
Henry Puddicombe was born in Beaford, Devonshire, England, in 1803. Son of John Puddicombe (1768 – 1848) and Mary Brinsmead (1766 – 1834). Grandson of William Puddicombe (1729 – 1809) and Nancy Alford (1738 – 1823), he was the fourth of eleven children. In what we can only assume became a rather cramped household Henry and a few brothers choose to take the risk and venture to the new land.
To understand Henry Puddicombe’s presence at St. James, one must look at the tight-knit family chain that migrated from Beaford, Devonshire, in the 1830s. The family’s transatlantic story began in 1832, when Henry’s older brother, William Puddicombe (1798–1877), endured a grueling six-week ocean voyage to Upper Canada. On that very ship, William met Joanna Balkwell, a chance encounter that led to their 1835 marriage in London by Dr. Benjamin Cronyn, later the First Bishop of the Diocese of Huron. William pioneered the farmstead that anchored the family in Wilmot, serving as a pillar of both Christ Church in Haysville and St. James, where he was laid to rest in 1877. Unfortunately, his stone has still to be located and may be lost forever, but the remaining records place him here as the first Puddicombe to enter Wilmot.
Following his brother’s path into the bush, Henry Puddicombe crossed the Atlantic to establish his own homestead in Waterloo County. Here, he wed Elizabeth Stockwell, a native of historic Cambridgeshire. The daughter of William Stockwell and Mary Greason, one of five children, Elizabeth would not be the only Stockwell to find rest in Waterloo County, a brother Thomas finds his name etched into a shared monument at St. James. Leading us to believe that Elizabeth did not arrive in Canada alone. Nor is Thomas the only brother on the monument.
Together, Henry and Elizabeth built a lasting legacy; clearing raw forest, raising a large family, and establishing themselves as pillars of parish life at St. James. Henry’s brother Robert Puddicombe (1800–1841) also joined the settlement, though his life was cut tragically short in 1841, leaving his name recorded on a shared memorial stone in Row 2 of the churchyard. Two brothers, two stones, one family.
Elizabeth passed away in mid-July 1872 in her 70th year, leaving Henry to navigate a decade without his lifelong companion until his own passing on May 2, 1882, at age 78.
Their monument stands as a proud piece of pioneer social history. Carved explicitly into the marble face are their English birthplaces; Beaford, Devonshire and Cambridge, a permanent testament to the long, courageous journey across the ocean that built their home in Wilmot Township.
Row 1 Stone 5: Sarah ‘Hutchisson’ Hutcheson(1765 – 1856)
To live to be 90 years old in the 19th century was a remarkable rarity; to do so after enduring an ocean voyage from Lincolnshire, England, to settle in the Upper Canadian bush is nothing short of heroic. But if any pioneer buried along this ancient tree line earned that title, it was Sarah.
· Inscription: IN MEMORY OF / SARAH, / RELICT OF / THOMAS HUTCHISSON, / NATIVE OF LINCOLNSHIRE, / ENGLAND, / WHO DIED JUNE 2, 1856, / IN HER 91ST YEAR. / "MY GOD AND FATHER WHILE I STAY, / FAR FROM MY HOME,
ON LIFE'S ROUGH WAY, / O TEACH ME FROM THE HEART TO SAY, / THY WILL BE DONE."
Sarah was born in Lincolnshire, England, around 1765, representing a breathtaking historical timeline to contemplate while standing in Row 1. Her birth predated the American Revolution, the French Revolution, and the arrival of the Huron Road survey crews by decades. Over her ninety-one years, she lived through the reigns of four British monarchs; King George III, King George IV, King William IV, and Queen Victoria, witnessing the complete transformation of Wilmot from an unbroken, dense hardwood forest into thriving, cultivated farmsteads.
Sarah was widowed early in her Canadian journey when her husband, Thomas, passed away in 1835 at age 50. Left to navigate life as a widow (relict) in the early days of Waterloo County's settlement, she persevered through more than two decades of pioneer widowhood, anchored by her family, her faith, and her community at St. James. Passing away on June 2, 1856, in her 91st year, she rests as one of the oldest individuals interred in the entire churchyard.
A fascinating detail on Stone 5 is the spelling variation of the
family surname. While Sarah’s stone clearly reads HUTCHISSON, her husband Thomas’s marker records the surname as HUTCHESON. In 19th-century cemetery research, these variations tell a compelling human story. When Thomas died in 1835, Sarah, as his surviving widow, would have provided the details to the stonecutter, handing down the established English family spelling. When Sarah passed away twenty-one years later in 1856, the task of ordering her stone fell to a child, executor, or local builder. Whether the order slip was written hastily or misread by the stonecutter, the spelling was permanently carved with an "iss" instead of the "es." Such variations were exceptionally common in pioneer Upper Canada, where phonetics and regional accents often dictated how names were translated onto marble.
Beneath her name and origins lies one of the most poignant epitaphs in the cemetery, featuring a stanza taken directly from Charlotte Elliott's famous 1834 Christian hymn, Thy Will Be Done: "My God and Father while I stay, Far from my home, on life's rough way, O teach me from the heart to say, Thy will be done." For an elderly Englishwoman who left the familiar green fens of Lincolnshire to spend her final decades on the frontier of Waterloo County, these words carry deep, emotional weight. They speak to the quiet resignation, endurance, and unwavering faith of a pioneer matriarch who made peace with living and dying far from her native soil, resting peacefully at last along the row of trees.
Row 1 Stone 6: John Claydon (1849 – 1931) and Jane Craggs (1855 – 1933)
Standing as a bridge between the early pioneer era and the transformation of the 20th century, the granite marker for John Claydon and his wife Jane Craggs speaks to a lifetime of shared devotion and quiet resilience.
Born in 1849, John lived through the booming mid-to-late Victorian era in Waterloo County. Coming of age in a landscape defined by manual clearing and hand-hewn timbers, he worked the land and witnessed the steady arrival of iron railways, modern steam-powered machinery, and the eventual paving of country roads.
· Inscription: In loving memory of John CLAYDON, 1849-1931. Jane CRAGGS, his wife, 1855-1933.
Jane Craggs, born in 1855, stood alongside him through decades of hard work and community changes. After John passed in 1931 at age 82; right around the time weekly regular services at St. James were drawing to a close; Jane followed him just two years later in 1933. Their clean, enduring granite monument stands in beautiful contrast to the soft, eroding marble surrounding them in Row 15.
Appearing in the marriage record of their daughter Charlotte Clayton Ludwig, you can trace this family from England to St. James, appearing on census records, family search and findagrave.
Row 1 Stone 7: Peter Acres (1824 – 1909) & Abigail Acres (1819 – 1907)
Perhaps one of the most fascinating origin stories in the entire churchyard belongs to the Acres family. Both Abigail Acres (born Valentine's Day, 1819) and Peter Acres (born July 1824) were born on the iconic Rock of Gibraltar; the strategic British military fortress on the southern tip of the Iberian Peninsula.
· Inscription (North side): In memory of Peter ACRES, born at Gibraltar, July 29, 1824, died in New Hamburg, Oct. 5, 1909.
· Inscription (South side): In memory of Abigail ACRES, born at Gibraltar, Feb. 14, 1819, died in New Hamburg, May 24, 1907.
Abigail Broadcomb was born on Valentine's Day, February 14, 1819, to her father, John Broadcomb, mother unknown, and five years later, on July 29, 1824, Peter Acres was born on the same Mediterranean fortress. To understand what makes their early life so extraordinary, one must picture Gibraltar in the early 19th century, as it was not a civilian settlement, but a tightly controlled, strategic garrison packed with British military regiments, naval personnel, and their families.
Being born on "The Rock" strongly points to a British Army garrison upbringing, where their fathers were deployed to guard the Mediterranean passage following the Napoleonic Wars. Growing up amidst stone ramparts, military drills, and ocean horizons, Peter would later follow in that same tradition, earning his status as a British Army pensioner.
In 1882, after decades of life connected to the British military, Peter and Abigail made the decision to cross the Atlantic, leaving the warm, rocky cliffs of Gibraltar behind to journey to Canada West and establish their home in the growing town of New Hamburg in Wilmot Township. While late-in-life migration was rare for seniors in the 1880s, Peter’s military pension provided the stability needed to make such a move, allowing them to settle close to parish life and community networks in Waterloo County.
It was through locating Abigail’s official 1907 death registration that the deeply human details of her final years came to light. Behind the stark medical listing of a five-year struggle with rheumatism lies a story of physical resilience; enduring half a decade of severe, crippling joint pain long before modern medicine could offer relief, Abigail was tenderly cared for at home by Peter. Passing away on Victoria Day, May 24, 1907, at the age of 88 years, 3 months, and 10 days, Abigail’s long journey finally came to a peaceful end. Peter, who stood faithfully by her side and personally served as the informant on her death record, survived her by just two years, passing away on October 5, 1909, at age 85, to be laid to rest alongside her.
To clear the lichen and moss from the Acres monument is to honor a journey unlike any other in St. James churchyard: a couple who traveled from the sun-drenched fortress of Gibraltar to the quiet soil of Wilmot Township, bound together by military service, lifelong devotion, and an extraordinary cross-continental story.
Row 1 Stone 8: Margaret McKenzie Cannard (1876 – 1935) - The Lost Marker
Row 15 holds one final mystery, standing as a stark reminder of why cemetery conservation is an urgent race against time. Official cemetery records and historic Ontario Genealogical Society (OGS) transcriptions log the resting place of Margaret McKenzie (1876–1935), wife of William Cannard. However, by the time researchers surveyed the yard during the August 2013 audit, her marker could no longer be located on the surface, listed simply as missing.
· Inscription (OGS Historical Record): Margaret McKenzie, wife of William Cannard, 1876–1935.
Born in West Zorra Township, Oxford County, to George McKenzie and Janet McFarlane, Margaret grew up in the rich agricultural landscape of Southwestern Ontario before marrying William Cannard. Her eventual burial at St. James anchored her memory to this quiet churchyard, yet over the decades, nature began to reclaim her spot.
For years, it was assumed that Margaret's stone had suffered the fate of so many soft markers; sinking deep beneath the turf from soil shifting, breaking apart under encroaching brush, or being displaced during past yard maintenance. Her lost presence drove home the very core purpose of our work at Eternal Care Stone Services: every time we probe the earth, reset a sunken base, or clean a forgotten face, we are searching for the voices silenced by time, ensuring those who sleep beneath the canopy are never erased from history.
Now, that cold case is finally breaking open. Deep beneath a thicket of wild raspberry bushes along the edge of Row 15, field probing has uncovered a hidden cluster of historic stonework. Resting beneath decades of soil and roots sits a base, a small footstone inscribed simply with Mother, a granite corner plot marker bearing the letter P, and a large tablet lying face down in the earth. While active clearance and delicate lifting are still underway to confirm the inscription on the face, the structural alignment strongly suggests we have located Margaret’s long-lost monument.
Uncovering her resting place bridges the gap between historical transcripts and physical reality, bringing a forgotten pioneer daughter of West Zorra back into the light after years in the shadows. Updates will follow as the stone is safely raised, cleaned, and documented, but for now, we can finally mark the spot where Margaret rests once more.
As the evening sun filters through the pines along Row 1, each freshly cleaned marker stands as more than just a piece of restored stone; it is a reawakened life. From the heart-wrenching loss of young Eva Maria Smith to the transatlantic journeys of the Puddicombe brothers, the quiet endurance of Sarah Hutchisson, and the extraordinary Mediterranean story of Peter and Abigail Acres, these pioneers built the bedrock of Wilmot Township. Bringing their names back into the light reminds us that history isn't just written in books; it is etched into the very ground beneath our feet, waiting for someone to clear away the moss and listen.
While the first row has yielded incredible discoveries; including the ongoing recovery of Margaret McKenzie’s lost resting place, our journey through St. James Anglican Cemetery is only just beginning. In the next post of our cemetery restoration series, we step forward into Row 2. A whole new chapter of Wilmot’s pioneer past lies waiting under the canopy, where we will probe for hidden tablets, piece together long-forgotten family lines, and uncover the resilient stories of the early settlers who laid down their roots right beside them.
Comments